“Diana’s home is a rental property,” proclaimed a recent
newspaper headline. Princess Diana’s brother, Earl Spencer,
according to reports, is offering the family’s ancestral home to
overnight guests, allowing them to sleep in the room where Diana
stayed with Prince Charles.
To travel agents who have been busy selling villa and home
rentals, news that their clients can now paddle around Diana’s
bedroom in their pajamas and fuzzy slippers did not come as a
surprise. Thousands of private homes, centuries-old villas,
apartments and condominiums have come on the market in recent years
as travelers’ appetites for spending their vacations in
accommodations with kitchens and living rooms in lieu of hotels has
been growing.
The popularity of traveling with family and friends is
responsible for the growth, not necessarily for estates as grand as
Diana’s Althorp, but for more modest accommodations such as private
homes and condominiums, said Tama Taylor Holve, president of
Willett Travel in Studio City, Calif.
“It’s such a natural and easy way to travel, particularly with
children,” she said. “When you’re staying at a hotel, you’re
looking at $15 each for breakfast and a few dollars each time the
kids want a soda.”
Travelers are also looking for more room to spread out.
“A great thing about a house or condo is that there’s a
gathering place,” said Holve. “If you’re traveling with friends and
family, rather than sitting on the beds to play Scrabble, you’ve
got a living room.”
The popularity of home rentals prompted Creative Leisure, the
Petaluma, Calif.-based wholesaler, to purchase Villas of
Distinction, a New York-based rental specialist, last year.
“It’s the fastest growing part of our business right now,” said
Frank Samson, Creative Leisure’s president and chief executive.
Factors to Keep in Mind
Rental homes are appealing to both high-end and budget
travelers, agents and suppliers say. The affluent can find the
amenities of a fine hotel, with private chefs, daily maid service
and even butlers and private chauffeurs. Those looking to trim
costs particularly with the dollar weak in Europe are finding
savings through sharing a home rental with friends and by cooking
more meals themselves.
Another reason for the popularity of rentals is more intangible:
the experience of living in an exotic place. Among the most popular
destinations are Italy, France, the Caribbean and Hawaii.
“Some people love living in another culture and this is a way to
do that,” said Allyn Kaufmann, co-owner of At Home in France, an
Ashland, Ore.-based rental agency. “You’re going to shop in local
shops and eat at cafes and restaurants with local people. When you
go into the same bakery two or three days in a row, people will
remember you.”
But finding the right match between client and appropriate home or
apartment is a challenge.
The Internet is loaded with home and condo rentals all over the
world. Experienced travel agents say choosing a solid and reliable
company is the most important step in the booking process. Villas
and apartments vary greatly in Europe, from those with simple
furnishings and tiny rooms to elegantly appointed palaces fit for
and perhaps previously used by kings.

At Home in France lists a studio apartment in the center of
Provence’s Aix-en-Provence with a sleeping alcove, small sitting
area and narrow balcony for $865 per week. On the other end of the
spectrum, Villas of Distinction offers a five-bedroom six-bath
antique-filled 12th-century villa in the Chianti hills of Tuscany,
with sitting rooms whose large windows overlook the swimming pool,
formal gardens, services of a maid for three hours per day, for
$6,005 per week.
Because clients are booking for a week or more and dissatisfied
clients will find it more difficult switching from a rental than,
say, changing from one hotel room to another finding an appropriate
place is critical.
“You want to go with someone you can trust,” said Willett
Travel’s Holve, who is also chairman of Signature Travel, the
Marina del Rey, Calif.-based agency network. “And, you want to know
that they are not just a clearinghouse but that they have literally
inspected the properties.”
Betsy Donley, Camelback Odyssey Travel in Phoenix, said agents
want to have confidence in the companies they are using.
“Villas are very tricky to sell and the information needs to be
updated constantly,” she said, “especially in Italy and other
places in Europe because from one year to the next the villa can go
down in quality. You really have to have a contact that knows the
villas and checks regularly.”
Donley’s agency uses Virtuoso partner companies to ensure high
quality.
“We had a case that a client went on the Internet and found a
villa they liked in Tuscany,” she said. “We had our onsite supplier
check it out personally. It looked darling on the Internet, and the
person who took the pictures did a great job because it turned out
it wasn’t nice at all.”
Some rental agencies personally check out properties; others
rely on descriptions and photos from the owners or management
companies that they represent. Unlike hotels, there are no
standards or rating systems for rental properties.
Wimco, a Newport, R.I.-based company with offices in Europe,
spends “a fortune” each year inspecting its properties, said Jan
Gordon, vice president.
“There are certain standards that the villas we represent must
maintain,” she said. “There is no star system for villas like
hotels so it’s a more informal way of observations and
standards.”
Villas of Distinction the Creative Leisure subsidiary, which is
a preferred supplier to several agency consortia and operates
Ensemble Travel’s private villa program works with foreign-based
companies that offer a total of 1,500 properties. But Villas of
Distinction sells only 1,000 of those; the other properties do not
meet its standards, Samson said.
Agents say they often feel more comfortable working with
companies with offices in the U.S., because they feel like if
something goes wrong it may be easier to work through U.S.
offices.
Laurette De Moro, of Worldview Travel in Santa Ana, Calif., said
she “leans heavily” on her agency’s Virtuoso-approved partners.
“We are fussy and we want the companies screened,” she said. “We
have five or six companies that we deal with and know that they are
reliable and can show photos of the pool and the rooms, and they
are presented correctly.”
Daphne Bransten, vice president of Casto Travel in San
Francisco, said sometimes things go wrong. The agency booked a
cottage in the Cotswolds for clients through a U.S.-based company
outside their partnership that agents had successfully used
previously. However, when the clients arrived they found the
cottage moldy and dirty. They moved to a hotel, and Casto Travel
had no luck getting a refund or even a phone call back from the
rental company and ended up having to reimburse the clients
$1,600.
But Bransten said this experience has not discouraged Casto
agents. They have booked villa rentals with great success, she
said. Her own family has stayed several times in villas in
Italy.
Such personal experience helps in selling to clients who are
aware they could book the villas themselves, but are willing to pay
for the agency’s knowledge and services.
“We can package the whole experience,” said Bransten, who uses a
Florence-based ground operator, One Step Closer, for special
services for her clients renting in Italy.
Agents can add services such as private chefs, car rentals and
day tours, creating packages to show customers who would otherwise
book properties directly that agents add value, said Camelback
Odyssey’s Donley.
“It’s a good source of income,” Donley said. “A lot of affluent
people don’t have time to fiddle around on the Internet to plan
something like this.”

Commission Policies
Some rental agencies pay straight commission to agencies, others
work on a net basis and agencies add a mark up or charge a fee.
Several well-known industry names Creative Leisure, Abercrombie
& Kent, among them have expanded into European villa rentals,
and consortia members with preferred agreements receive overrides
as well as standard commissions.
Many of the agencies, however, do not aggressively court agent
business. At Home in France’s Kaufmann said profit margins do not
allow her company to pay commission. Nonetheless, about 5 percent
of her business is from agents, who mark up the rates or add a
service fee.
“We’ve invested a lot of time and energy in personally visiting
every property and we know the owners and property managers. Agents
appreciate that,” she said.
Wimco pays 10 percent commission on its rentals (7.5 percent on
villas in St. Bart’s) and makes an effort to work with agents,
which make up 13 percent of its business. But Gordon concedes that
the company doesn’t want to raise commissions much further because
of the narrow profit margins that commissions slice even
narrower.
“We’re not trying to cut commissions or discourage bookings, but
we’re not trying to increase them either,” said Gordon. “We want to
work with agents, but increasing business with agents would
diminish our revenues.”
Some agents may take exception to the way companies operate.
Vacanza Bella, an Italy specialist with offices in Rome and San
Francisco, pays agent commission, with the rate depending on the
property. But the firm prefers that, after first describing the
client and their needs, agents have clients call Vacanza Bella
themselves.
“If a booking takes place, then I bill the client through the
travel agent,” said Daniel Morneau, company president. “Often,
travel agents don’t want to turn their clients over to me because
they fear that I will run away with the client and not pay
commission and that the client will feel that the agent has not
done the work. If they can’t overcome that fear, then I can’t work
with them.”
Most rental bookings are still done on the telephone, but there
are signs that booking homes and condominiums may be getting
easier. A three-year-old company, Leisure Link of Pasadena, Calif.,
created an electronic marketplace that connects agents with
vacation rental suppliers worldwide through the major GDSs.
The company offers 300 commissionable properties in 75
destinations from two sources: management companies that have pools
of privately owned homes and timeshare companies.
“Our suppliers love us because we deliver more bookings by
virtue of our partnerships with GDSs,” said Kelly Tompkins, Leisure
Link president and founder.
The firm offers incentive programs for agencies who book through
the GDSs and a Web site that also offers booking capability,
although agents do not receive commission for Web bookings and work
off of net rates.
John Valerio, owner of Crown City Travel, also in Pasadena, said
using Leisure Link has resulted in more bookings and customer
retention.
“We lost out on a lot of Hawaii and ski resort bookings because
properties often don’t pay commissions, or owners go direct. A lot
of clients don’t feel they can get the rentals they want through
agents and we would have to charge fees for our time, but using
Leisure Link, I’ve been able to book places that are commissionable
and nowhere else to be found,” he said.
Not for Everybody
Even with the huge range of rentals and destinations available,
there are some clients that may not be candidates for this type of
vacation.
De Moro noted it’s a vacation for people who don’t want to move
much.
“If they want to see a lot of different areas it doesn’t work
because you have to plop yourself in one place at least a week,”
she said.
To qualify customers, she often asks what they want to see in
the area: if they talk about places that are more than a couple
hours’ drive, she suggests a traditional hotel vacation.
Clients also would not be happy if they are seeking a lot of
interaction with other people.
“Couples traveling alone looking to socialize are much better
off in a hotel and resort,” because they may find themselves
isolated in a home, said Wimco’s Gordon.
Crown City Travel’s Valerio said any client who seems rigid
would not be a good candidate for a rental in a foreign
country.
“We’re talking about 200-year-old places with no dishwashers and
leaky faucets. Sometimes you’ve got to have a good sense of humor
and roll with the punches,” he said.
Others who may not be happy in a rental are overworked mothers,
said Valerio.
“They’ll tell me when they get back that they didn’t like having
to do the dishes,” he said.
On the other hand, even if you have to do a few dishes, what
other type of travel affords the opportunity to live like a
princess in an estate like Diana’s, or to shop like a French
housewife while walking the cobblestone streets of a medieval
village?
“You’re living like a real local person and immersing yourself
in another culture,” said Perkins.
ITALIAN VILLA VACATIONS
Renting a villa in Italy has become so popular that idyllic scenes
of couples lounging in centuries-old villas, shopping at village
markets and feasting on food and wine have become a travel cliche.
But the romantic notions that Americans bring to their vacations
in Italy fueled by books and movies such as “Under the Tuscan Sun”
can be shaken when reality does not live up to fantasy. By renting a villa or an apartment in Italy, clients are
agreeing to not merely visit a foreign country but to live as a
local in a place where everyday life can be very different from
life in the U.S. Daniel Morneau, owner of Vacanza Bella, a Rome-based company
specializing in Italy (with a U.S. office in San Francisco),
emphasizes that the appealing aspects of renting a villa in Italy
far outweigh the problems adjusting to a different way of life and
clients should be prepared to adapt with a sense of humor. To make sure that clients are prepared, his Web site
(www.vbella.com) has caveats for those who have never lived in
Italy. Here are some examples from Morneau and from my own
experiences renting in Italy of factors that clients should be
aware of before taking the plunge:
--- Water is sometimes at a premium. Eight people who insist on
taking half-hour showers each day in August may find that the water
will run out. The same goes for electricity. --- There are bugs. For Californians and others who live in
areas without a lot of insects, this may come as an unpleasant
surprise. Window screens are not in widespread use in Italy. But
various mosquito-repellent devices are used in homes and can be
bought at any grocery or hardware store. --- Towels are not the same as home. Europeans do not use as
many towels as Americans, and the towels provided are typically
smaller and thinner. --- Washing machines are usually provided, but dryers are rare.
Because electricity is expensive (and because they prefer the fresh
smell of laundry hung outside) most Italians do not have dryers.
Laundry is hung on clotheslines outside or on racks indoors. --- Beds can be odd sizes. Large beds are called matrimoniale,
and they are wider than an American queen-size bed but smaller than
king-size. Italian twin beds come in two sizes: about the same as a
standard American twin and another size much narrower (which might
be uncomfortable for the average American). Very common in rentals
are matrimoniale beds made up of two standard-size twin beds pushed
together so that the owner can accommodate as many types of guests
as possible. Couples may worry that if the beds are pushed
together, they will fall through the crack, but mattress covers and
bed linens are all sized for these beds and visitors rarely
notice. |
TIPS FROM THE EXPERTS
Renting a villa or vacation home has its risks, say travel agents
and suppliers. But there are steps travel agents can take to
protect themselves and their clients and help ensure an enjoyable
vacation.
--- Work with a company that has an office in the U.S. Even though
some of the best prices are found by dealing directly with European
agencies, if there are problems, it will be more difficult getting
help or negotiating a settlement. “You can’t take a European
company to small claims court,” noted Ed Perkins, a syndicated
writer and formerly ASTA’s consumer advocate.
--- Work with a company with which your travel agency or
consortium has a long-standing preferred agreement. Many well-known
U.S. tour operators have expanded with villa rental offerings and
agents can receive commissions, plus overrides. --- Push trip cancellation insurance. Many rental companies
require a hefty deposit 50 percent for booking a villa vacation and
then full payment 60 days or more in advance. There is usually no
provision for refunds. Because large groups often rent villas
together, the chance that an emergency may occur or another reason
for canceling a trip arises is greater than usual, so trip
cancellation insurance is essential, say agents.
--- Be careful about property descriptions. Another reason to work
with a company you trust is that owners may exaggerate the
attributes of their villa or apartment, making it seem more
attractive, better located or larger than it actually is. Photos
taken with a wide-angle lens make even a closet look spacious, said
Perkins. Many agents have now added villa and condo inspections to
their lists of things to do while traveling.
--- American coffee machines are not always available. Some
homes that cater to Americans offer American drip coffee machines,
but if coffee is important make sure to check before booking. CONTACTS At Home in France
No commission available
www.athomeinfrance.com Abercrombie & Kent
Commission available
www.abercrombiekent.com Creative Leisure
Commission available
www.creativeleisure.com
www.villasofdistinction.com Leisure Link
Commission available
www.leisurelink.com Vacanza Bella
Commission available
www.vbella.com
Wimco
Commission available
www.wimco.com |