When Karen Kuck of Texas found out she needed a new hip, the cure
sounded worse than the disease: $90,000 in medical costs, a stint
in a rehab facility and little chance of returning to her active
lifestyle.
“I just about freaked out,” said the 53-year-old Kuck, who is
one of 47 million Americans without health insurance. “I like
adventure vacations kayaking in Alaska and things like that. I
don’t want to be a fragile little creature that can’t do
anything.”
Kuck started surfing the Internet for alternatives. She quickly
learned about a more promising and less invasive procedure called
hip resurfacing, which was not yet approved by the FDA but was
being performed overseas at a fraction of the cost of a hip
replacement in the United States.
With the help of a Southern California-based company called
PlanetHospital, Kuck underwent the resurfacing procedure at a
private hospital in New Delhi, India, in early November. Two weeks
later, the single retiree and her “marvelous little hip” were
recuperating back home in the Dallas suburb of Waxahachie. Total
cost? $16,500, which included all hospital charges, roundtrip
airfare for two (a girlfriend came along for moral support) and 11
nights at the five-star Hotel Nikko New Delhi, three meals a day
included.
Kuck is one of the growing number of Americans mostly uninsured
or underinsured who are traveling overseas to get medical and
cosmetic treatment they can’t afford or can’t get in the United
States. Breast augmentation in Thailand? Full-smile dental veneers
in Panama? A heart bypass in India? It’s all available at
bargain-basement prices for those willing to take the leap of faith
to undergo medical treatment in a foreign country.
Medical tourism packages often include sightseeing at popular
tourist destinations and pampered stays in luxury hotels. The South
Africa company Surgeon and Safari offers cosmetic, dental, eye and
orthopedic surgery at top-notch hospitals, along with a side trip
to enjoy trumpeting elephants and snorting hippos oblivious to the
swollen faces and sutures. MedRetreat, a Chicago-area medical
tourism company, books patients undergoing treatment in Penang,
Malaysia, at the six-star Eastern and Oriental Hotel, a boutique
property built in 1885.
The National Coalition on Health Care in Washington, D.C.,
estimates that 500,000 Americans traveled out of the country in
2005 for medical or dental work. Fueling the phenomenon are
America’s 78 million baby boomers, the oldest of whom turned 60
this year. Many lack adequate health insurance just as their bodies
are beginning to break down and cosmetic surgery starts to look
more appealing.
The stampede into overseas operating rooms has spawned a cottage
industry of medical travel and tourism companies, most of which
have relationships with hospitals and surgeons in countries like
Singapore and Thailand, where the quality of private medical care
is high but labor and materials costs are low.
Rudy Rupak, co-founder and president of PlanetHospital, is
sending five to 10 patients a day overseas.
“We have a package for Costa Rica and Thailand, air, hotel,
transfers, meals and breast augmentation for $4,995,” Rupak said.
“Now keep in mind that’s with a high-quality doctor who is board
certified in the U.S. That doctor would be charging $8,000 to
$12,000 for the same procedure in the United States.”
MedRetreat has sent a total of 550 people for medical treatment
abroad 80 percent for cosmetic work but increasingly for orthopedic
procedures like Kuck’s hip surgery.
“We have another 430 waiting to go and that’s without spending a
dime on advertising,” said Patrick Marsek, MedRetreat’s managing
director. “It’s quite overwhelming.”
A Growing Market
Demand for low-cost, high-quality medical care will grow even
more as the baby-boom generation begins its slow, final decline
around 2015, writes Frederick J. DeMicco, ARAMARK endowed chair in
the Hotel & Restaurant Management program at the University of
Delaware, who has studied the phenomenon. Facing higher costs in
the United States, some American health insurance companies have
even begun paying for low-cost overseas medical care.
Despite the strong market indicators, however, medical tourism
appears to be off the radar screen for travel agents. ASTA reports
no medical tourism specialists among its members. Several agents
questioned for this story said they had never sent anyone overseas
for medical treatment at least knowingly and most expressed little
interest in doing so. The consensus was that it just seemed too
scary, with liability a big concern.
“We love all of our clients,” said Pat Fulton of Departures in
Mesa, Ariz., and secretary of Arizona ASTA. “I would feel dreadful
if I sent somebody for major surgery and it didn’t turn out.”
“I would be very afraid to be involved in it because of the
issue of liability,” said Susan Tanzman of Martin’s Travel and
Tours in Los Angeles.
Maureen Kaye, senior vice president for the Berkely Group, which
specializes in insurance products for the travel industry, said she
would decline outright an application from a travel agent or tour
operator engaged in medical tourism.
“General liability policies typically have a medical-services
exclusion,” Kaye explained. “Even if you had an insurance company
that was willing to offer a travel agent or tour operator a
liability policy, chances are that policy is going to have an
exclusion directly related to medical malpractice, so it would be
useless anyway.”
But what makes medical tourism so different from high-risk
adventure travel?
“The whole purpose of the trip is to offer medical services, and
the only reason travel agents are involved is to get the patient
from point A to point B,” Kaye said.
Rupak and Marsek said the liability issue is not insurmountable.
Both said their companies are not in the business of providing
medical services, but rather act as facilitators. Patients must
sign liability waivers.
“If it’s a problem with surgery, we have no control over that.
[The patient] would have to seek some kind of solution with the
hospital,” Marsek said.
Kaye said waivers “will help with the defense, but that does not
prevent a claim from being filed.” She added that one workable
solution might be for medical facilities to include booking agents
in their liability coverage. Rupak said the facilities he works
with do not do so.
Rick Thues, 53, a Southern California computer consultant who
went through PlanetHospital for a hip resurfacing in India, said he
had no qualms about getting treated outside the United States.
Thues found PlanetHospital in an online newspaper article.
“You think of a foreign country as being not as good. But the
hospital was cleaner than any I had been in here, and the hospital
staff was more experienced. The surgeon had done about 200 [hip
resurfacings],” he said.
Some hospitals and clinics used by medical tourism companies are
accredited by the Joint Commission International, a branch of the
U.S.-based Joint Commission on Accreditation of Healthcare
Organizations. Among them is Johns Hopkins Singapore International
Medical Centre, affiliated with the prestigious university in
Baltimore, Md.
To win accreditation, a facility must meet “very rigorous
international standards of both clinical care and hospital
operations and management anything from infection control to
patient rights,” said Anne Rooney, a vice president with the Joint
Commission International.
While accreditation is no guarantee of a happy outcome for the
patient, “there are hospitals in different parts of the world where
I would feel absolutely comfortable in terms of medical care and
cleanliness,” Rooney said.
Still, she advises patients to do some sleuthing on their own to
find out about a hospital’s reputation.
Travel agents whose databases brim with the demographic that
medical tourism companies are targeting could be a potential gold
mine for the industry. Several companies said they’re eager to work
with travel agents, if the agents can put aside their fears.
“I believe medical tourism can revive the travel agency
business,” Rupak said. “Most of the agents who are in business
today are there because they have an excellent network of clientele
who are either empty nesters or baby boomers.”
PlanetHospital will pay up to 15 percent commission on the
travel portion.
“We’re also exploring a flat payment per package,” Rupak
said.
GlobalChoice Beauty & Wellness, an Albuquerque, N.M.,
start-up that specializes in cosmetic surgery holidays in
Singapore, Turkey and Costa Rica, is in discussions with a
prominent retail travel consortium to advertise commissionable
vacations to clients, said Alaina Paradise, GlobalChoice’s
marketing director. She declined to name the consortium.
Participating travel agents would be required only to register
clients at the GlobalChoice Web site. After that, a GlobalChoice
account manager would take over, Paradise said.
“This is a fantastic opportunity for travel agents,” Paradise
said. “In addition to providing them an additional opportunity to
make commission-based revenue, it’s giving them an entirely new
product.”
Paradise said the commission rate would be “attractive” and
would be based on the entire cost of the package, including the
medical portion.
Marsek hasn’t yet worked out an arrangement with agents, “but if
they have an interest in a program like this, call us and we’ll
talk about the possibilities.”
MedRetreat makes money by taking a 20 percent cut of the
hospital bill.
“It’s extremely advantageous for a client to come to us because
it’s not going to cost them a dime more,” Marsek said.
PlanetHospital charges patients a $295 consultation fee and
takes commission from hospitals.
Marsek said patients are better off going through a medical
tourism company than purchasing services on their own.
“If somebody just goes there on their own and there’s a problem
situation, what’s the worst that’s going to happen to the hospital?
They lose one client. Whereas with our company, they stand to lose
an entire account,” he said.
Thues said he was “treated like a VIP” at the Max Super
Specialty Hospital, where Kuck also underwent surgery. When Thues
contracted a minor stomach ailment after his surgery, a physician
from the hospital promptly called him in his hotel room, diagnosed
his condition and phoned in a prescription. That same afternoon, a
PlanetHospital concierge, who was at Thues’ disposal during his
two-week recuperation at a hotel, picked up the medication and
delivered it to Thues.
Thues sought treatment in India because his HMO refused to
authorize the procedure, which would have cost $40,000 out of
pocket in the United States, or $22,000 through his wife’s PPO. The
tab in India: $12,000, including roundtrip airfare for Thues and
his wife, and accommodations at a three-star hotel.
Emerging Markets
Healthcare systems in developing countries see medical tourism
as a financial boon. Experts predict that medical tourism could
bring India as much as $2.2 billion a year by 2012, according to
Marvin Cetron, president of Forecasting International, quoted in
the University of Delaware’s UDaily. Thailand expects to earn more
than $1 billion this year alone from medical tourism, according to
a story in The Nation newspaper.
Bangkok’s JCI-accredited Bumrungrad Hospital, a pioneer in
attracting well-heeled foreign patients, has 200 board-certified
doctors on staff. About 40 percent of patients treated at
Bumrungrad come from abroad, many from rich Middle Eastern
countries, according to DeMicco. Last year, Hawaiian singer Don Ho
checked into a Thai hospital for an experimental stem cell
procedure on his heart. The famed crooner credited the procedure
with saving his life.
While companies like PlanetHospital focus on treatment over
tourism, others are marketing sightseeing opportunities as a
powerful inducement. GlobalChoice Beauty & Wellness hopes to
carve a niche in a crowded field by selling escorted, cosmetic
surgery packages to groups. In particular, Paradise said women
recuperating from cosmetic surgery in a foreign country feel more
comfortable in the company of companions who are similarly sore and
sutured.
With so many uncertainties, the role of the travel agent in
medical tourism isn’t yet clear. What is clear, however, is that
agents who are interested in this trend need to keep an eye on this
growing niche and jump in only when they are comfortable with the
risks.
| Countries for Medical Tourism
Thailand: A longtime leader in this type of tourism due to its
hospitality, well-trained medical personnel and famous Bumrungrad
hospital in Bangkok. Specializing in everything from dental work to
sex-change operations.
India: Top-notch centers equipped with the latest medical
equipment make this country popular for open-heart surgery,
pediatric heart surgery, hip and knee replacement and other
procedures. Costa Rica: A mecca for North Americans seeking plastic surgery
without a trans-Pacific flight. South Africa: Attractive exchange rates make this a favored
destination for plastic surgery. (Source: Frederick J. DeMicco, ARAMARK endowed chair, Hotel
& Restaurant Management program, University of Delaware.)
The Price of Beauty So how much can your clients save by going overseas for their
cosmetic surgery? Here are some sample offerings. Liposuction in Thailand: $5,995, includes air, hotel and a
personal attendant (through PlanetHospital) Breast Augmentation in South Africa: $4,550, includes hotel and
one-day safari (through Safari & Surgeon) Face and Neck Lift in Malaysia: $2,800, covers medical expenses
only (through MedRetreat) Nose Job in Costa Rica: $3,695, includes air, hotel and a
personal attendant (through PlanetHospital) Tummy Tuck in Brazil: $4,800, covers medical expenses only
(through MedRetreat) |
| CONTACT The Berkeley Group
800-797-4514
www.berkely.com
GlobalChoice Beauty & Wellness
877-858-0123
www.globalchoicehealthcare.com Joint Commission International
630-268-2900
www.jointcommissioninternational.com MedRetreat
877-876-3373
www.medretreat.com PlanetHospital
800-243-0172
www.planethospital.com Surgeon & Safari
27-11- 463-3154
www.surgeon-and-safari.co.za |