Surveys, statistics and studies are the life’s blood of the travel
industry. So, it’s surprising to come across an information gap
involving a major segment of the travel agent profession. That’s
been the case for quite some time, however, when it comes to the
home-based agent community.While some proselytize for the Web and
the future of online distribution, and traditionalists trumpet
specialization and service and see a resurgence in large
brick-and-mortar agencies, home-based agents remain one of the most
vocal and most intriguing segments of the industry as much for what
is known about them as for what’s still a mystery.
There’s a lot of mystique (some would say hype) surrounding this
group. Travel industry organizations and publications have for over
a decade been talking about a growing number of agents that have
chosen to leave storefronts, offices and call centers behind, to
work more independently at home. For a variety of reasons, this
group’s perceived significance to the industry has increased in
recent years, despite the fact that relatively little is actually
known about them. Opinions about these agents are often based on
anecdotal evidence and defined by assumptions. Those assumptions
have at times stirred executives up into a fever of exuberance. At
the last ASTA World Congress, for example, former ASTA president
Richard Copeland described the home-based agent community as no
less than “an army in the shadows.”
In discussions with industry executives, it’s clear that while
much is still unknown about this “shadow army,” two things are
almost universally accepted as fact: 1) the home-based agent
community has been very difficult to quantify; and 2) their numbers
are growing. In an effort to go beyond these limited views,
Northstar Travel Media, the parent company of TravelAge West, and
Stanley Plog, one of the travel industry’s most respected
researchers, teamed up for an exclusive study into the home-based
agent community. The results of this study were published last
month in Travel Weekly, the sister publication of TravelAge West,
and they provide the clearest look to date into this distribution
channel.
While some of the results may be surprising, the study combined
with the views of experts and the actual experiences of agents in
the field ultimately shows that there is no cookie-cutter
definition of the modern travel agent. Instead, the reality of
today’s agent distribution system is far more messy and hard to
define.
Who Is the Home-Based Agent?
One of the biggest questions regarding home-based agents
has always been the overall size of this segment, with estimates
seeming to run high or low based on whether it’s coming from a
supporter or a detractor. An accurate count of this group is hard
to come by. Today most experts in the field put the size of the
home-based community in the U.S. at somewhere around 20,000 agents
(plus or minus a couple thousand). Mark Murphy, publisher of
several home-based agent magazines, uses this figure, for instance.
With approximately 200,000 travel agents in the U.S., that makes
the home-based agent community 10 percent of the whole. Perhaps not
an “army in the shadows,” but a significant niche
nonetheless.
Considering all the attention paid to the home-based agent
community, it is surprising that basic information about them has,
to a large extent, been hard to obtain. Thanks to the
Northstar/Plog study, however, a clearer picture is emerging. For
example, approximately 57 percent of home-based agents sell travel
full time, 77 percent are women and their average age is 55. About
58 percent of them belong to a chain or consortium and most sell
leisure travel.
One of the most surprising factors to come from the study is that
the average time in the travel industry for this group is 14 years,
and 60 percent have previously worked as a retail agent. Another
surprising fact is that the vast majority of these agents didn’t
move home because their brick-and-mortar agency closed, as many
have speculated, but because they wanted greater control over their
work lives.
Going beyond this basic information, however, some industry
insiders have come up with their own definition of these agents.
Dr. Marc Mancini, one of the travel industry’s best known speakers
and consultants, and for the past 18 years an educator at West Los
Angeles College, has worked with hundreds of home-based agents.
Based on this experience he divides the home-based segment into
three types. “Dilettantes” are not really serious about selling
travel as a profession, although they may book travel for family
and friends. They love to travel and are interested in the
perceived perks of being an agent (making them a prime target for
card mills and other scams). At the other end of the spectrum are
the “Pros.” They have many years of experience in the industry and
are usually former brick-and-mortar agents that have decided to
move home for personal reasons. Finally, there are the “Rising
Stars.” This group is new to the business often older,
career-changers but despite their lack of experience they take the
profession seriously and intend to educate themselves in order to
succeed. They are generally tech savvy and their choice to start a
home business is often financial, intended to reduce the overhead
of a new business.
According to Mancini, all of the agents have one thing in common:
a continued need for diligent training.
“By definition, home-based agents need more training. Even those
who were quite successful in brick and mortar need to continue
their education now more than ever. They’re missing out on the
water-cooler talk and the learning by osmosis that goes on when
you’re in the midst of a busy travel selling location,” says
Mancini.
While the Northstar/Plog study doesn’t attempt to classify agents
into any particular categories, it does examine the differences
between full-time and part-time home-based agents. Not
surprisingly, part-time agents have significantly fewer clients and
make far less revenue. Part-time agents are less likely to have a
business-related Web site than their full-time counterparts,
perhaps suggesting a higher degree of professionalism among
full-time agents.
Professionalism is another major area of concern when it comes to
home-based agents. While in public suppliers throughout the
industry praise home-based agents for their seriousness, behind the
scenes there are still a lot of questions about just how
professional some home-based agents really are. For instance, in
the Northstar/Plog study, only 13 percent of cruise executives and
17 percent of tour operators described home-based agents as
“professional and capable.” In fact, overall home-based agents
received low scores from cruise and tour executives on “product
knowledge,” “background and training,” “professional and capable,”
“serious and dedicated” and “creative in developing new
programs.”
In an interview with Travel Weekly, Plog noted that suppliers
still have lingering questions about home-based agents.
“No one really believes they produce a significant portion of
revenue, and it’s true that a home agent cannot deliver the volume
that large agencies can. Suppliers wonder how much attention to pay
to them,” says Plog.
Regardless of the survey results, most executives at least on the
record describe very positive experiences dealing with home-based
agents.
“The growth of the home-based agent segment is one of the most
important trends in the cruise industry in terms of impact. It’s a
fantastic development, says Jan Swartz, Princess Cruises’ senior
vice president.
Out of 15,000 travel agents enrolled in the online Princess
Academy training program, 27 percent or close to 4,000, describe
themselves as home-based, says Swartz.
Money Matters
One of the most startling findings in the Northstar/Plog
study is related to the amount of money home-based agents earn, as
well as the amount of travel they sell. According to the
respondents, before factoring in business expenses, the average
home-based agent sells $220,000 and earns $21,000 per year. There’s
a significant difference here between full-time and part-time
agents, with full-time agents booking $310,400 for a profit of
$29,100 and part-time agents selling only $99,600 and earning
$10,200. Only 7 percent of full-time agents earned $75,000 per
year, and 5 percent earned over $100,000 (as opposed to 2 percent
and one percent for part-timers).
On a per-hour scale, these earnings are quite low adding up to
approximately $13.50 per hour for full-time agents and $10.20 per
hour for part-time home-based agents (based on the number of hours
per week reported by respondents).
While there are certainly some home-based agents that are
exceptionally high earners, the average home-based agent would be
hard pressed to make a living on this salary. In fact, a recent
Outside Sales Support Network (OSSN) study reinforced these
results. The largest number of respondents in any category nearly
one-quarter (22 percent) reported year-end gross travel sales
volume at less than $5,000. On the other end of the scale, only 1.5
percent reported gross sales of $1.5 million, according to the
survey.
These results are backed up by anecdotal evidence, as many travel
suppliers interviewed for this story reported only “one or two”
home-based agents among their top 100 producers.
In addition, suppliers in the Northstar/Plog survey reported on
the revenue brought in from home-based agents when compared to all
agents. On average, cruise, airline, hotel and tour executives said
that 58 percent of their sales came from travel agents, and 12
percent were from home-based agents. By industry, this breaks down
to airlines (22 percent, all agents, 3 percent for home-based);
cruise (62 percent, versus 5 percent); hotels (36 percent, and 13
percent); and tours (75 percent, and 16 percent). These numbers are
significantly lower than some have speculated.
In terms of what products home-based agents sell the most, the
breakdown shows a strong preference for cruises, but tours are a
stronger component than some might have expected. On average,
full-time and part-time home-based agents reported selling: cruises
(43 percent), tours (29 percent), air (10 percent), hotels (9
percent), rental cars (4 percent) and other (5 percent). Perhaps
not coincidentally, 60 percent of respondents named cruise lines as
best supporting home-based agents, with 36 percent picking tour
companies. This suggests supplier education efforts such as the
Home-Based Success Series, sponsored by the Globus family of
brands, Royal Caribbean, Celebrity Cruises and NACTA are probably
worth the effort.
Continued Growth
It is no small task to assess the importance of the
home-based agent market to suppliers. Certainly the segment has its
cheerleaders.
“It’s very pure and simple. Fifty percent of our agent members are
home-based. They’re critical to the health and well-being of the
cruise industry,” says Terry L. Dale, president and CEO of the
Cruise Lines International Association.
“Some of the top-producing agencies we work with use a network of
home-based agents,” says Gary Murphy, president of Brendan
Worldwide Vacations.
Murphy singles out one agency in particular America’s Vacation
Center (AVC).
“They’ve got a really good mousetrap, and one of the reasons
they’re so successful is that they don’t let just anyone join,”
says Murphy.
Indeed, the San Diego-based AVC (part of the American Express
network) is considered by many as a prototype for the successful
home-based agency model. With hundreds of agents across the
country, the company is a veritable home-based powerhouse.
“We’re very picky about who we accept into our program. But, once
they’re in, we offer support like no other host agency, in terms of
education, technology and mentoring, just to name a few areas,”
says AVC co-president Brad Anderson.
That support is clearly paying off, says Anderson.
“Our agents are producing 10 to 20 times the average income of
agents at other host agencies. Some of them are netting more than
$100,000 per year,” he says.
Not everyone is as enthusiastic about the strength of the
home-based agent market, however. Susan Tanzman, ASTA’s 2005 Agent
of the Year, thinks the home-based phenomenon is overblown.
“The reality is that this is just an extension of what we’ve
always had. Most agencies had independent or outside sales agents
who worked from home. It’s really no different from what it’s
always been,” says Tanzman.
Tanzman also sees a sinister side to the cruise industry’s support
of independent home-based agents. She wonders if it isn’t a good
way for them to put pressure on the larger travel agencies, which
often command greater commissions and more support.
Regardless of what anyone says pro or con about home-based agents,
there is little doubt among experts that their numbers are growing.
Yet, as the home-based segment continues to grow, the overall
travel agent distribution system seems like it’s becoming more
fragmented and independent. Whether the home-based channel will
continue to flourish in this ever-changing market remains to be
seen. In the meantime, many suppliers will continue to root for the
“home” team.
“We do believe in it, and will continue to invest in training and
other support for the home-based agent community,” says Douglas
Duncan, vice president, sales, Globus family of brands.
Duncan also made this prediction about home-based agents: “The
more training they get, the more their confidence rate grows, and
with that, sales. It’s not yet a mature channel, but we’re very
excited about their potential, and we want to deal with them.
They’re very much a part of our business now.”
And, perhaps, a “shadow army” after all?
SURVEY METHODOLOGY:
Stanley C. Plog, Ph.D. conducted his research for Travel Weekly
and TravelAge West by interviewing travel executives, consortia
members, travel-trade associations and home-based agents. To reach
agents, Plog relied on questionnaires e-mailed to 12,664
recipients. A total of 9 percent or 1,064 usable responses were
returned, which Plog determined sufficient to provide a margin of
error between 3 and 4 percent. Plog’s responses from travel
suppliers were obtained from e-mail questionnaires sent to 77
executives in four groups: airlines, cruise lines, tour operators
and hotels. Forty respondents provided usable answers, for a return
rate of 57 percent. The supplier sample was not large enough to
access a margin of error, but sufficient for meaningful analysis.
Plog also conducted telephone interviews with leaders of
travel-trade associations and consortia.
| A TALE OF TWO AGENTS
Is this the best of times for home-based agents? TravelAge West
wanted to know, so we set out to interview travel agents operating
on both the home front and the storefront, and in some cases, a
combination thereof. What we found is that business models vary
almost as much as agents themselves do. In short, ask any two
travel agents to explain their business today, and you’ll end up
with two different tales. That’s particularly true with agents
working from home.
In order to get some perspective on home-based travel sellers, we
checked in first with some traditional brick-and-mortar
establishments. We began in Las Vegas, where the travel-selling
industry is alive and well, thanks to a booming population and
large concentration of affluent retirees. Family-owned Prestige
Travel & Cruises is the largest agency in Nevada, with 200
employees in 16 branch offices throughout the Las Vegas valley.
Co-owner Ellen Falkensammer attributes the agency’s ongoing success
to the fact that clients are “still interested in that personal
touch.”
Ling Irwin is one of Prestige Travel’s top agents. A veteran of
more than twenty years in the business, Irwin’s office in the
spacious, tastefully furnished Prestige Travel Executive Center, is
a bustling center of business.
Irwin tried working from home a few years ago, but found that she
missed interacting with clients.
“I prefer to have an office to go to, with set business hours and
a business-like atmosphere,” says Irwin, as she greets the first of
many clients on a recent day.
The clients a retired couple from Boulder City, Nev., have driven
45 minutes from their home to pick up some travel documents. They
thank Irwin for her time, and for all the details she’s taken care
of. As she bids them a warm bon voyage, Irwin reminds them that she
is already at work on their next vacation itinerary a cruise to
Australia and New Zealand.
“We have a lot of upscale people coming in here, and they really
expect personal service,” says Irwin. “These days, people spend a
lot of money on travel. The clients expect professionalism, and
working from home would not be the same.”
Not far from Irwin’s office, another Las Vegas travel seller,
Lydia Santiago, is hard at work. Santiago’s office happens to be in
her master bedroom. But, she feels every bit as professional as a
denizen of brick and mortar.
Santiago is part of the new breed of home-based agents, working
since 2004 with America’s Vacation Center. Before that, Santiago
worked at an Expedia call center. She decided to join AVC because
it fulfilled her longtime goal of working from home.
“I can be my own boss. I can work as hard as I want to or as
little as I want to,” says Santiago.
Without the constraints of a traditional office, Santiago is free
to pick up her granddaughter, or take care of other family needs
during the day. She can forward her calls, or take her laptop with
her, allowing for maximum flexibility. The key is being organized,
says Santiago.
She is particularly pleased with the AVC business model, because
of the technical, professional and educational support the company
provides. Conference calls, instant messaging and a buddy system
ensure that at-home agents don’t feel isolated. In Santiago’s mind,
she’s enjoying the best of all possible worlds.
“Everything we do at home still works the same way as it does in a
retail office. But, there’s no downtime from a long commute. And,
no wasted time with ‘lookey-loos’ who aren’t serious about
booking,” she says.
“Some days I literally roll out of bed and hop on the computer.
It’s hard to beat that,” adds Santiago.
Chris Van Beveren, owner of Beck Travel in Chatsworth, Calif.,
also works out of an office-bedroom. But, she doesn’t consider
herself a typical home-based agent.
“I call myself a travel agency owner,” says Van Beveren.
In the business for nearly three decades, Van Beveren used to run
Beck travel from a retail storefront with 35 agents. Changes in
airline commission structure made her decide to close the office,
though. She tried merging with another agency for a short period of
time, but that didn’t work out. Eight years ago, Van Beveren set up
shop in a spare bedroom at home. A number of her agents stayed with
her, and now operate out of their homes, as well. But, she doesn’t
refer to them as “home-based.”
“I call them outside agents, because that’s the term the industry
has always used. I don’t see any reason to change the terminology
now,” she says.
Van Beveren operates Beck Travel in a manner that’s “not much
different” from her retail shop days. She kept her ARC number, and
belongs to the Ensemble Network. Van Beveren’s home office
certainly looks like a typical travel agent storefront, complete
with posters lining the walls, shelves filled with cruise-line
catalogs and filing cabinets full of client records. Only the
friendly calico, “Sammy,” purring on Van Beveren’s lap gives the
location away.
The home-style touch doesn’t seem to put off Van Beveren’s
clients, however. A group of neighbors rings her front doorbell,
arriving for an afternoon appointment. One of them remarks that Van
Beveren was highly recommended by another local couple, known for
their extensive travel.
Van Beveren is lucky, in that her affluent neighborhood of
sprawling ranch homes provides fertile ground for new sales leads.
She says suppliers have taken to her home office, just as clients
have.
“In the beginning, suppliers definitely thought it was weird that
I worked from home, and they wouldn’t pursue appointments with me.
But, in the past three or four years, they’ve been telling me that
working from home is a trend. Lots of suppliers now tell me that
half of their accounts are home-based,” says Van Beveren.
Though she may work from home, Van Beveren says she wants to be
included with “mainstream” travel sellers, not lumped in with other
home-based agents with whom she may have little in common.
“The bottom line is that the public wants someone who is
professional and knows what they’re talking about. It doesn’t
matter where they do business,” she insists.
Adeline Castiglione couldn’t agree more. The home-based agent
lives not too far away from Van Beveren, in Granada Hills, Calif.
She’s a prime example of someone who segued into the travel-selling
business with a strong affinity group behind her.
Castiglione and her husband volunteered for the Archdiocese of Los
Angeles for 20 years, conducting marriage encounters. After
retiring from that endeavor, Castiglione decided to become a travel
agent. She worked a short while at a brick-and-mortar agency, but
quickly realized she should be in business for herself. Her church
contacts, it seemed, were as good as gold.
Castiglione set up a business at home by converting two unused
bedrooms into an office. Sweet Adeline’s Travel & Tours, Inc.
quickly grew from a classic “mom-and-pop” agency to a tour company
specializing in escorted tours and cruises.
Religious travel was a no-brainer. So, Castiglione also launched
Adoration Tours, specializing in “Pilgrimages at Sea,” an exclusive
cruise product in conjunction with Holland America Line.
A member of Ensemble, Castiglione’s entire operation including the
printing of brochures takes place out of her home. She even hosts
pre- and post-trip gatherings for tour groups there. Castiglione
advertises in Catholic newspapers, but most of her business is from
word of mouth and repeat customers.
“We did over $2 million in sales last year,” she says.
From the looks of things, Castiglione’s unique brand of home-based
business shows no signs of slowing.
“We have a great relationship with our clients, and we’re giving
them personalized service. I know there are a lot of people who
don’t believe it’s possible to achieve this working out of your
home. But, we have certainly proven them wrong,” she says.
Kevin Prime transitioned to the home-based model in 2002, after
losing the lease on his Portland, Ore., office. He and his wife run
their two-person agency, Cruise Clearinghouse, from the walk-in
basement level of their suburban Hillsboro home.
Going home-based certainly came with some trade-offs, however.
Some of Prime’s former clients don’t want to drive to the suburbs.
Others are happy they don’t have to drive in to Portland. Clients
who want to drop by in person are welcome to do so. The Primes keep
business hours Monday through Friday and sometimes on Sunday.
“One of the pitfalls of working from home is that there are lots
of distractions. It’s too easy to do the laundry instead of answer
the phone. We have five lines going to our basement office. And,
during the day, we don’t answer our home phone,” says Prime.
Prime says that if he had not lost the lease on his Portland
office, he may still be doing business there.
“I’m not quite sure if what we’ve done is a formula for success.
We’ve made mistakes. What we save in rent, we’ve had to spend on
marketing,” he says.
Prime’s agency is a member of Vacations.com. And, Prime like Van
Beveren from Beck Travel doesn’t believe the term “home-based
agent” applies to him.
“We don’t know what to call ourselves, actually. It’s a little
weird. We have a Web site, but we’re not totally Internet-based.
We’re not a hosted agency. We’re retail, but we’re not at a
traditional retail site. Maybe we’re a home-based retail store,” he
laughs.
Prime adds that one of his big concerns is the health of the
travel agent industry in general. He fears that not many new people
are entering into the business.
TravelAge West managed to track down a few newcomers, Kenyata
Hatter and Staci Blevins. Both women, in their 30s, are enrolled in
travel industry courses at West Los Angeles College. Hatter is the
mother of two young children, married to a basketball player with
an international league. Travel is already an integral part of her
lifestyle, and she’s eager to expand those opportunities by
becoming a travel seller. Blevins is a former attorney interested
in starting a business with her recently retired mother.
Both Hatter and Blevins are intrigued with the notion of selling
travel from home. But, that’s not the case with Charlotte Adams, a
new agent with Prestige Travel in Las Vegas. In contrast to her
more seasoned counterpart, Ling Irwin, Adams’ offices are on the
casino floor of the Suncoast Hotel.
A former massage therapist and obvious “people person,” Adams
seems to thrive in the vibrant setting. Her clientele includes
locals as well as hotel guests seeking that evening’s hottest show
tickets. From her glass-walled office, Adams has already witnessed
a few million-dollar jackpot wins on the slot machines outside her
door. She considers it a good omen for a career that’s already off
to an impressive start. In her first few months, she’s already made
some prime bookings and accumulated a binder full of certificates
from agenttraining courses
Asked why she didn’t choose the home-based route, Adams admits she
knows little about it.
“It doesn’t sound like something I’d be interested in. I’m not
even sure how that would work. But, I’m sure there is plenty of
business to go around,” says Adams.
The entire industry could hardly agree more. |