It’s impossible to ignore the faltering U.S. economy with Wall Street’s meltdown translating into tougher times for many travel agencies. But the fiscal downturn shouldn’t eclipse what the latest surveys compiled for TravelAge West’s annual review of the industry show to be bright spots for those with the ingenuity and versatility to profit from increasingly budget-minded travelers.
 In uncertain economic times, the West could come out ahead of the rest
|
This year’s breakdown, headlined by industry researcher Stanley C. Plog’s Travel Industry Survey (TIS) of agents and supplemented by other industry reports, looks at the shifting travel landscape and provides a survival guide for anxious agents who watched the industry shrink by 651 agencies, or 3 percent, last year. Agents, the survey shows, now worry more about the "soft U.S. economy" than terrorism.
Plog’s TIS evaluates the industry’s performance nationally and regionally in 2007 with the West defined as the TravelAge West 14-state circulation area of Alaska, Arizona, California, Colorado, Hawaii, Idaho, Montana, Nevada, New Mexico, Oregon, Texas, Utah, Washington and Wyoming.
The West, it turns out, had more of a cushion entering the economic downturn following strong sales of $41.6 billion last year, a 10 percent increase over 2006. That’s 14 percent higher than the average for the rest of the nation. Higher sales volume in the West translated to an average of almost $7 million per agency, outpacing the average agency nationwide by 22 percent.
Agents last year again capitalized on westerners’ love of travel despite rising airfares and fees by offering opportunities closer to home. With air sales flat at about $11 billion, domestic cruise sales shot up 21 percent to $10 billion; tour bookings jumped 22 percent to $4.6 billion; and the resort trade grew 10 percent to $5.4 billion.
"I’m pleasantly surprised by the way the agencies that are still here are getting more successful," Plog told TravelAge West. "They’re starting to learn how to do it by placing emphasis on certain products. Cruising is a growth industry, tours are important, as are spas and resorts."
The most recession-resistant companies offer customized products around-the-clock to a loyal customer base appreciative of quality getaways, analysts say. America’s Vacation Center, one of the world’s largest agencies based in Miami and San Diego, reported double-digit September sales over a year ago with executives citing customers’ enthusiasm for river cruises and other niche cruises, high-end escorted and exotic tours, more adventurous travel and a variety of other specialty packages.
Brad Anderson, the company’s co-president, said agencies poised to flourish in a weaker economy — amid an Internet culture offering vanilla airline tickets, hotels and car rentals at a keystroke — are specialists who sell invaluable expertise using effective online outreach while outsourcing tasks like marketing or accounting.
"Consumers will be buying differently than they did last year," Anderson said. "They want to do their research online [but] then they want to talk to a specialist. Get out of simple transactions — people buy online. Try something you love to do: cruises, vacation packages or tours. Get an education: you don’t have a lot of time. This will play out over the next couple of years."
Anderson said those products are more insulated from rising airline prices predicted by the Official Airline Guide to depress domestic flights by 11 percent and capacities by 9 percent through the end of the year.
 The popularity of cruising is growing in the West.
|
John Whitmore, an independent contractor with World O’Travel in Woodland Hills, Calif., said his specialty line in expedition and small-ship travel is holding steady particularly among older clients unwilling to delay their "bucket list" of destinations, from the Galapagos Islands to Nome, Alaska. Whitmore emphasized looking ahead by spending extra time with budget-strapped clients to help them envision future vacations for when the economy rebounds.
"You have to be building dreams right now. You have to work with them. Ask them, ‘Where would you want to go if you could?’ Good trips aren’t built in a week, they’re built over a period of months," he said.
Eric Maryanov, president of All-Travel an L.A.-based agency with a nationwide client base, said only a couple of cancellations have been economy related, with overall sales comparable to last year’s and new bookings on pace for 2009.
"We’re proceeding with caution and concern and watching the numbers," Maryanov said. "What we’re doing is proactively marketing and reaching out to clients more than we ever have before to find out their interests and really catering to those. There are a lot of new deals and values, too."
The 2008 TIS query of 399 western agencies and 888 agencies across the country taps the uneasiness over the market. More agencies are worried they will sell fewer airline tickets, even for low-fare carriers, book fewer hotel rooms and see a decline in sales of vacation packages, escorted tours and ocean and river cruises compared to 2007. Only one-third were strongly optimistic profits would climb over the next few years.
Analysts said agencies using the old "brick-and-mortar" model reliant on standard issuance of tickets are rightfully pessimistic. But, Douglas Quinby’s review of travel trends for industry research firm PhoCus Wright of Sherman, Conn., finds agency owners and managers nationwide increasingly adopting creative strategies focusing on "more complex travel such as cruise, vacation packages and independent itineraries, where commissions are still relatively high and more experience and expertise is needed."
Quinby told TravelAge West successful agents have become travel consultants. The stars of the industry now are, "very service-centric and customer-centric; they are very knowledgeable, very service oriented; they really communicate value and not simply price."
The agent with insider advice on the best hotel offering exceptional beach access, a first-class pool and colorful bartender — along with a guarantee problems will be resolved promptly — is most likely to get repeat customers.
 Travelers in the West enjoy fine-dining experiences.
|
With the nation’s 18,000 ARC (Airlines Reporting Corporation) agencies representing half the number they did in 1996, better understanding customers and their nuanced needs is imperative, analysts said. Western travelers were identified as older and more experienced and adventuresome than peers across the country in a June study by YPartnership of Orlando, Fla. Four in 10 in the West want "to stretch themselves to try new things;" three in 10 for the rest of the country. Westerners prefer country music and jazz, are relatively "less stressed out," and are "technology savvy." They are more in tune with physical activities: hiking, snorkeling or scuba diving, bicycling through countrysides; or whitewater rafting. They are less inclined to travel with children, however, with 65 percent searching for family opportunities compared to 71 percent in the rest of the nation.
"At a time like this, you don’t cut back on marketing, getting your name out there and engaging with your clients even if they travel less," Quinby said. "It’s a common knee-jerk reaction in a crisis for a business to pull back on marketing, to pull back on public relations. But, that’s the time, if not to ramp up, to think about the most judicious way to invest in it."
Plog reminds agencies that good e-mail lists are inexpensive, as are fact-filled newsletters. E-mail continued to be agencies’ preferred method for attracting new clients last year, followed by Web sites and newsletters.
"Emphasize great places at affordable prices," Plog said.
Propose affordable compromises: a less-expensive, three-star hotel instead of a four-star, he advised.
"The message should be, ‘It’s a great time to escape, to recover psychologically, to recharge the psychic battery," he said.
Research shows westerners don’t need much nudging because they’re accustomed to traveling more often and for longer stretches. Agencies can expect clients to return, even if the economy doesn’t keep pace.
"People eventually say things aren’t getting better, but we’re not enjoying ourselves, so let’s take a trip even if we can’t afford it. We’ve had enough of cabin fever. People will take a trip even if it’s on a credit card," Plog said.
The winners then will be the agencies who stayed in touch with clients with well-priced, thoughtfully designed destination packages offering a tonic to the economic blues.
Fast Facts
Travelers residing in the West differ in many ways from those in the other parts of the U.S. Below are some examples of preferences that differentiate the West from the rest.
67% Prefer to go places that are more than just entertainment and where they can also get a sense of participation.
60% Prefer spending money on experiences that will enrich their lives, like vacations, theater, good restaurants, etc.
44% of travelers in the West (vs. 55% in the rest) say their lifestyle would be seriously affected if the economy takes a downturn.
Source: YPartnership 2008 Leisure Travel Monitor
Desirable Attributes In A Leisure Travel Experience
Less Desirable | West | The Rest |
A hotel or resort with a distinctive theme or atmosphere | 18% | 24% |
Being able to gamble | 16% | 20% |
A hotel with a formal and elegant atmosphere and decor | 14% | 22% |
Going to a destination spa that offers complete spa and wellness program | 13% | 20% |
More Desirable | | |
Hiking and outdoor adventure | 35% | 28% |
Snorkeling or scuba diving | 31% | 22% |
Bicycling trips through the countryside | 24% | 16% |
Whitewater rafting | 21% | 12% |
| Source: YPartnership 2008 Leisure Travel Monitor |
Factors impacting travel agency business
The following factors had a negative impact on agency business in 2007:
59% Rising air fares and fees
49% Increased costs of travel
42% Devaluation of the dollar
40% Soft U.S. economy
38% Airport hassles, delays
37% Internet-based competition
17% Security (terrorism fears, etc.)
14% Natural disasters
11% Unfavorable opinion of U.S.
7% Health issues (bird flu, SARS, etc.)
Source: Stanley C. Plog’s 2008 Travel Industry Survey
Outlook Pretty Good
TIA forecasts a stable travel market despite economic woes
The Travel Industry Association (TIA) today released its annual travel forecast indicating that an uncertain economic climate is leading American and global travelers to change their behaviors. Although leisure travel is stable, business travel is projected to decline and the U.S. is likely to be hit hard by a further decline in international arrivals.
"Consumers are responding as we might expect during an economic slowdown," said Dr.
Suzanne Cook, senior vice president of research for TIA. "But travel should not simply be viewed as an economic indicator; it should be seen as a part of the solution to our economic woes. There’s no doubt that if we can spur travel, we can help to turnthe economy around."
Despite current economic conditions and lagging consumer confidence, the forecast shows that leisure travel volume remains stable for 2008 (-0.2 percent) and is expected to decline modestly in 2009 (-1.3 percent). According to the latest TravelHorizons survey co-authored by TIA and Ypartnership, seven out of 10 (71 percent) respondents intend to take an overnight trip of 50 miles or more from home in the next six months. Fully half (48 percent) of all respondents stated they were not planning any changes to their future travel plans as result of the recent turmoil in the financial markets.
According to Dr. Peter Yesawich, chairman of Ypartnership, "The results corroborate what we have been preaching now for several months: American travelers are trading down, but not out."
Consumers are likely to plan and purchase leisure trips differently with the pursuit of a "good value" as the primary reason why. Three quarters (76 percent) "expect to book a packaged vacation to save money" and six out of 10 (58 percent) "plan to comparison shop for prices and rates specifically on the Internet." Seven out of 10 (67 percent) "plan to stay fewer nights" and a comparable percentage expects to "spend less on food, beverages and entertainment" when traveling.
"By no means is the sky falling," said Dr. Cook. "After years of growth, we’re now looking at modest declines. The travel industry can manage the downturn, but it is in the country’s interest to stimulate travel as one of the best means to stimulate our economy."
www.tia.org
Only Online
Scroll down for information on the Travel Industry Association's 2009 Travel Forecast