TravelAge West
Search Sponsored by

Explore TravelAge West

Destinations

Back
  • Africa & Middle East
  • Asia & South Pacific
  • Caribbean
  • Central & South America
  • Europe
  • Hawaii
  • Mexico
  • USA & Canada

Travel Types

Back
  • Family
  • Adventure
  • Cruise
  • River Cruise
  • Tour Operators
  • Luxury
  • Hotels
  • Culinary
  • Romance
  • Wellness
  • Sustainability

Directories

Back
  • Hotels
  • Cruise
  • Job Seeker Center

Interactive

Back
  • Click & Win
  • Geo Quiz
  • Slideshows & Video

Professional Development

Back

Industry Insight

  • Business Features
  • Interviews
  • Events
  • Opinion
  • Tech
  • Podcasts
  • Coronavirus and Travel
  • Need to Know Research

Education

  • Certifications
  • Digital Guides
  • Fams
  • Thought Leadership
  • Advertiser Spotlight
  • Webinars
  • Immersive Family Experiences

Events

  • Global Travel Marketplace
  • GTM West
  • WAVE Awards
  • Future Leaders in Travel Retreat

Sign Up for Our Daily Newsletter

I accept the T&C and Privacy Policy.

Search TravelAge West

Clear Field
Dana RebmannContributing Writer

Share

  1. Home
  2. Travel
  3. Hotels

The National Exchange Hotel Vs. Holbrooke Hotel in Northern California

Feb 17, 2022
California  Hotel Reviews  Hotels and Resorts  
The National Exchange Hotel Vs. Holbrooke Hotel in Northern California
The Holbrooke Hotel was established in 1852 and has been recently renovated.
Credit: 2022 Kat Alves

Emerging from an extensive, multi-year restoration, a pair of California’s oldest hotels — The National Exchange Hotel in Nevada City and the Holbrooke Hotel in Grass Valley — are giving guests a new way to strike travel gold.

Built during the Gold Rush, both hotels offer the romance and intrigue that guests crave, but with an upscale and modern experience that this stretch of Gold Country has never seen before, thanks to massive renovations undertaken by Santa Barbara, Calif.-based Acme Hospitality.

Anthony Jones, general manager of The National Exchange Hotel, was raised in Northern California and grew up visiting Gold Country. Well-versed in the area’s lore and history, he said he considers the properties museums.

RELATED: 8 New and Renovated Hotels to Book in Northern California’s Wine Country

“We are docents first,” Jones said. “We are here to share the history of this place, both the good and the not-so-great. But that is our charge, to not only offer hospitality in the present, but to be the voice of what was happening here [in the past].” 

Sign Up for Our Daily Newsletter

I accept the T&C and Privacy Policy.

We are here to share the history of this place, both the good and the not-so-great. But that is our charge, to not only offer hospitality in the present, but to be the voice of what was happening here [in the past].

The hotels, both California Historical Landmarks, are located less than a 10-minute drive from each other; during my recent visit, I spent a night at each. Despite being built during the same stretch of notable history, the bones and personality of each hotel are dramatically different.

The Differences Between Holbrooke Hotel and The National Exchange Hotel

The Holbrooke Hotel — established in 1852 — features 28 guestrooms spread throughout the main structure and a separate building that once served as a carriage house. With brick and native stone walls, leather furnishings, cowhide rugs and a myriad of animal taxidermy, the property’s first-floor public spaces embrace the Old West spirit of Grass Valley. 

Upstairs, a more refined approach dominates the halls and guestrooms. No two rooms are alike; some boast balconies, clawfoot tubs and even small tables where a couple could dine or enjoy a glass of wine. Some rooms are spacious with high ceilings, while others are smaller and more in line with accommodations you might expect in a city hotel.

Rooms at the Holbrooke are all unique.
Rooms at the Holbrooke are all unique.
Credit: 2022 Kat Alves

From writers such as Mark Twain, Jack London and Bret Harte to outlaw Black Bart, a long list of famous folks is known to have enjoyed the hospitality of the Holbrooke throughout the years. And though it’s difficult to prove with certainty, hotel registries also name a handful of U.S. presidents as past guests. Ulysses S. Grant, James A. Garfield, Grover Cleveland, Benjamin Harrison and Herbert Hoover may have also roamed these halls at some point in history. 

Meanwhile, The National Exchange Hotel, established in 1856, is a Victorian charmer. Vibrant William Morris wallpaper covers walls at every turn in the property’s public spaces, and in all 38 guestrooms. Featuring vintage furniture and antiques (some original, some sourced and some even donated by the community), no two rooms are exactly the same. 

“Every room has its own special magic,” Jones said. “Part of that is because we have been given so many wonderful treasures to work with.”

The National Exchange Hotel’s guestrooms are filled with vintage furniture and antiques.
The National Exchange Hotel’s guestrooms are filled with vintage furniture and antiques.
Credit: 2022 Kat Alves

The National once served as a boarding house (part of the remodel included adding bathrooms to every room), and I admit I was a  bit starstruck when I learned my room was where President Hoover once stayed.

Clients living with mobility issues should note that there is no elevator in The National. Travelers with any hesitation about using stairs should be booked on the second floor, as it can be accessed directly from the hotel parking lot.

Where to Eat and Drink at Holbrooke Hotel and The National Exchange Hotel

The historic properties mark Acme Hospitality’s entrance into the hotel business. And since the company is well known in Southern California for its food and beverage concepts, it’s no surprise that eating and drinking is a main draw at both properties. 

The Golden Gate Saloon at Holbrooke opened its doors to thirsty prospectors a year before lodging was an option, and is said to be the longest-operating bar west of the Mississippi. (Though there is a friendly debate about whether those bragging rights should actually belong to the bar at The National Exchange Hotel.) The Golden Gate Saloon flows into the restaurant, where I was impressed with everything I tasted — from huevos rancheros and roasted sweet potatoes with charred red onion, queso fresco, piloncillo and piment d'ville, to a tuna tostada that combined sashimi-grade yellowfin tuna, avocado, purple radish, lime, cabbage, red onion and green onion on a fried blue-corn tortilla

The Golden Gate Saloon at the Holbrooke includes a restaurant.
The Golden Gate Saloon at the Holbrooke includes a restaurant.
Credit: 2022 Ingrid Nelson/Myrtle and Marjoram

Tucked away in Holbrooke’s cellar, the Iron Door bar has a reputation for frequent paranormal activity, perhaps because in addition to once serving as a brothel and speakeasy, it was also a morgue. Numerous stories recount spooky encounters in the women’s bathroom with a lady dressed in Victorian clothing.

Dishes at The National’s Lola restaurant have French flair — think: French onion soup topped with melted gruyere, smoked salmon mousse with potato gaufrettes and dill, and steak frites with truffle butter. Dedicated to the women of the Wild West, the walls of the neighboring National Bar are adorned with photos of women who defined the era.

The National Bar
The National Bar
Credit: 2022 Kat Alves

There are several clever and thoughtful design touches throughout both properties, but the actual bar in The National Bar is one of my favorites. Repurposed radiators, salvaged from rooms above during Acme’s remodel, line its base. Beautifully executed, it’s a hospitality experience that makes Gold Rush history easier to swallow.

Tell Us What You Think! forum

Related Content

evergreenlodgeyosemitenationalpark

Hotel Review: Evergreen Lodge Near Yosemite National Park

  • Most Read
  • Most Shared
  1. When Will the Brightline to Orlando Open? New Details Released
  2. The Top Hotels in Mexico for a Romantic Getaway
  3. A Travel Agent's Guide to Pet-Friendly Travel Planning
  4. What to Know About Waikiki Beach Marriott's Renovation, According to Its New General Manager
  5. Review: Hilton Hotel Tahiti
  1. 6 Unforgettable Chateau Experiences in the Loire Valley
  2. The Caribbean’s Newest Theme Park: Katmandu Park Punta Cana
  3. The Top Hotels in Mexico for a Romantic Getaway
  4. When Will the Brightline to Orlando Open? New Details Released
  5. What Is It Like to Travel to Saudi Arabia?

From Our Partners

More Stories Like This

isthebrightlineorlandoopen

When Will the Brightline to Orlando Open? New Details Released

What to Know About Riding on the Alaska Railroad

What to Know About Riding on the Alaska Railroad

‘Expressions of America’ Opens at the National World War II Museum in New Orleans

‘Expressions of America’ Opens at the National World War II Museum in New Orleans

Why a Day Cruise Is Ideal for Visiting Kenai Fjords National Park

Why a Day Cruise Is Ideal for Visiting Kenai Fjords National Park

Oakland Like a Local_HERO

40-Time Jeopardy! Winner Amy Schneider Shows Us How to Best Explore Oakland, California

Review: Hotel Californian in Santa Barbara, California

Review: Hotel Californian in Santa Barbara, California

Review: Conrad Los Angeles

Review: Conrad Los Angeles

The Top 10 Most Popular Destinations for Thanksgiving

The Top 10 Most Popular Destinations for Thanksgiving

What’s New in California's Santa Ynez Valley, From New Hotels to Must-Eat Restaurants

What’s New in California's Santa Ynez Valley, From New Hotels to Must-Eat Restaurants

4 of the Best New Restaurants in Las Vegas

4 of the Best New Restaurants in Las Vegas

TravelAge West

About TravelAge West

  • About Us
  • Contributors
  • Sales Team
  • Contact Us
  • My Profile

Advertise

  • Advertise With Us
  • Write For US
  • Media Kit
  • Upload Ad Material
  • Digital Ad Specifications
  • Reprints
  • Subscribe to Print

Stay Connected to TravelAge West

Get Us in Your Inbox

I accept the T&C and Privacy Policy.


Northstar Travel Group

Northstar Travel Group

  • Travel Weekly
  • Travel Weekly Asia
  • Travel Weekly China
  • TravelPulse
  • TravelPulse Canada
  • TravelPulse Quebec
  • Meetings & Incentives
  • Travel Technology
  • Corporate Travel
  • Hotel Investment
  • Data Products
  • AGENTatHOME

Copyright © 2023 Northstar Travel Media, LLC. All Rights Reserved. 301 Route 17 N, Suite 1150, Rutherford, NJ 07070 USA | Telephone: (201) 902-2000

Load Carousel Here
Load Video Here